Chanel Initiation Illusion D’Ombre Eyeshadow review, swatches, comparisons.

Chanel Initiation Illusion D'Ombre.

Chanel Initiation Illusion D’Ombre.

Chanel Initiation Illusion D'Ombre.

Chanel Initiation Illusion D’Ombre.

I am not one to go out and hunt down limited-edition products.  My cosmetic defense mechanism kicks-in and reminds me, repurchase is futile.  However, when Chanel Nuit Infinie de Chanel Collection started appearing on blogs and reviews started flooding in, I knew Chanel Initiation Illusion D’Ombre ($36 US/ 4g) was the one color in this LE collection that was worth the pursuit.  Mind you, it took four major department stores to track down this color.  The things I will do for this blog.  Was it worth it?  You’ll see…..

The Pros:

  1. Beautiful antique gold color with micro-fine gold, copper and silver sparkles.  What a combination!
  2. Sanitary and sturdy packaging.
  3. Price/amount ratio is a good value.
  4. Initiation reminds me of my beloved Illamasqua Ore Pigment.
  5. The sparkles are lightweight and abundant.
Left: Illamasqua Ore Pigment. Right: Chanel Initiation Illusion D'Ombre.

Left: Illamasqua Ore Pigment.
Right: Chanel Initiation Illusion D’Ombre.

The Cons:

  1. Initiation has a very faint brown base, color build-up is not possible.
  2. The color seems to be consisted of pure sparkle.
  3. The formula is not on par with other Illusion D’Ombre (reviewed here).  The sparkle’s texture is not as densely packed as Vision or Fantasme.  Initiation’s performance reminded me more of MAC pressed pigments (not good).
  4. There does not seem to be a sufficient binding agent within the formula to allow the sparkle to adhere to the lid.  The fallout is ridiculous!
  5. This particular color seems to have had issues with shrinkage (as seen on many other blogs); presumably due to the drier texture and lack of a dense color base.
  6. After one hour the sparkles migrated from my lids to my face.
Chanel Initiation Illusion D'Ombre over Shu Uemura M895.

Chanel Initiation Illusion D’Ombre over Shu Uemura M895.

I had to place Chanel Initiation over a matte color, otherwise the camera would not have picked-up the color.

Comparison to Chanel Initiation Illusion D’Ombre:

As stated earlier, I was so excited to get this color solely because of its resemblance to Illamasqua Ore Pigment.

Left: Illamasqua Ore Pigment. Right: Chanel Initiation Illusion D'Ombre.

Left: Illamasqua Ore Pigment.
Right: Chanel Initiation Illusion D’Ombre.

Swatch: L-R: Chanel Initiation Illusion D'Ombre and Illamasqua Ore Pigment.

Swatch: L-R: Chanel Initiation Illusion D’Ombre and Illamasqua Ore Pigment.

Illamasqua Ore Pigment with Sephora Glitter brush.

Illamasqua Ore Pigment with Sephora Glitter brush.

My love for Ore Pigment has sparked countless recommendations.  Every time I wear Ore, people want to know what it is and how to apply it best.  Ore Pigment (or any pigment for that matter) can be applied with ease and zero fallout with the Sephora Glitter Silicone Brush (discontinued but, MUFE  and E.L.F both have a version of this brush in their line).  Simply dip the brush into the pigment, tap off the excess and press the brush onto your lid.  My only criticism with Ore Pigment has to do with the packaging.  I find the container impractical and cumbersome.  Hey ho…the actual pigment inside is stellar!  Oh how I wish Initiation had Ore’s pigmentation, longevity and adhesion.

Left: Illamasqua Ore Pigment. Right: Chanel Initiation Illusion D'Ombre.

Left: Illamasqua Ore Pigment.
Right: Chanel Initiation Illusion D’Ombre.

I applied Initiation with my ring finger and then gently patted the color across my lid .  The hand swatch for Chanel Initiation was quite promising, but the color pay-off and performance on the lids was beyond disappointing.

Chanel Cosmetics can be found in any department store.  Macy’s, Bloomingdales, Neiman Marcus, Lord & Taylor, even Century 21 and Chanel.com.  Currently, chanel.com does not carry this color, you will be able to find Initiation in person at Saks and online at Nordstrom.com.

Illamasqua Cosmetics can be found exclusively at Sephora and Sephora.com

THE VERDICT:  If makeup could talk what would it say?

Makeup would tell you to skip Chanel Initiation Illusion D’Ombre.  This particular color does not adequately represent the Illusion D’Ombre range.   For my needs, this color did not live up to my expectations; I wanted noticeable color with some sparkle.  Certain people’s penchant for Initiation will be due to it’s subtly, although the fallout will be a deal breaker for many others.  For my part, I will be exchanging Chanel Initiation. In the meanwhile, Maverick “if you feel the need, the need for speed” (Top Gun bro) then get your antique gold/bronze fix with Illamasqua Ore Pigment.  You will not be disappointed.  Be well and stay safe.

-M-

*Ifmakeupcouldtalk.com is not affiliated with any brands mentioned, all products were purchased by me.  Compensation is not given for any reviews.  Click on each photo to enlarge. *Click on the rose highlighted words to take you to a direct link to each product. *All photos are property of Ifmakeupcouldtalk.com unless otherwise noted.

 

About Maria Pia

A blog about beauty (what else), what makes me smile and life with two boys and a dog. This blog is about positivity and inspiration sewn in with a little humor. Makeup is not serious, but how we feel after we apply it, is no joking matter!!! I'm here to share my tips and tricks I have learned on my own for the past %&^$% years :) Enjoy my lovelies.

Questions, Comments, or Concerns?